DoorDash Dilemma: Should DoorDash Drivers Cherry Pick Orders?

The World of DoorDash: Empowerment or Exploitation?

I've been hearing a consistent buzz from friends and Reddit threads since . The chatter? Whether DoorDash drivers should cherry-pick orders. It's a debate that's generating more heat than a jalapeño popper, leaving many to wonder: Are drivers in the gig economy truly independent contractors or just pawns in a much larger game? Ever since 2023, I've been seeing people talk non-stop about whether DoorDash drivers should choose only the good orders. It's a big argument that's getting hotter than a spicy jalapeño popper, making people question if gig economy drivers are really their own bosses or just playing a role in a bigger scheme. 

What is Cherry Picking in DoorDash?

In the DoorDash landscape, cherry picking refers to the practice of selectively choosing orders based on the highest potential earnings. Essentially, a Door Dash driver evaluates each new order’s payout, tip, and distance before deciding to accept or decline it. Instead of automatically accepting every order that comes their way, cherry-pickers exercise their freedom as independent contractors to choose the most profitable dashes. This way, they aim to maximize their hourly pay while reducing time spent on low-paying orders.

So why did cherry-picking start in the first place? One reason could be the inconsistency in pay and tips that DoorDash drivers face. Given the fact that base pay and tips fluctuate, drivers started cherry-picking to secure better earnings. With the rising cost of gas prices in 2023, drivers have become even more selective, focusing on orders that make the most financial sense. In a gig economy where DoorDash driver pay can sometimes hover close to minimum wage, it's no surprise that cherry-picking has become a survival strategy.

Cherry-picking is pretty straightforward within the DoorDash app. When an order pops up, the app provides details such as the restaurant location, delivery distance, and the total payout, including tips. DoorDash drivers can either accept or decline based on these details. If you decline an order, your acceptance rate may take a hit, but the freedom to cherry-pick remains yours. Some food delivery workers skip the customers that don't tip. Others base it on their rate per mile.

However, it's worth mentioning that not all DoorDash drivers agree with the ethics of cherry-picking. Some argue that it could lead to a lower acceptance rate, thereby reducing the likelihood of becoming a Top Dasher. Others point out that constantly declining orders may decrease the number of dashes available to them, especially during busy times. Still, in an economy where each dasher wants to make at least a decent hourly wage, the temptation to cherry-pick is ever-present.

The Pros and Cons of Cherry-Picking

Pros:

Freedom to Choose

The gig economy is all about being your own boss. As a DoorDash driver, the freedom to cherry-pick means you get to choose which deliveries you want to accept or decline. Traditional 9-to-5 jobs don't offer this level of control. In 2023, the ability to curate your own DoorDash delivery experience is a game-changer.

Instead of accepting every order, you can focus on those that align with your goals. Ever gotten stuck in a bad order with long wait times at a restaurant? Cherry-picking enables you to avoid such scenarios and dash on your own terms.

Better Hourly Pay

Opting for higher-paying orders directly impacts your DoorDash driver pay, increasing your hourly earnings. When delivering food, especially as a DoorDash driver, maximizing your per delivery payout is crucial.

By cherry-picking orders that promise better tips and base pay, you put yourself in a prime position to make more in fewer hours. And let's be honest, who wouldn't want to get more bucks for their mileage?

Cut Down on Mileage

The life of a delivery driver isn't easy on your vehicle. When you cherry-pick orders that are closer in proximity, you directly cut down on mileage. Lower mileage not only means less wear and tear on your car but also savings on gas prices.

Cons:

Acceptance Rate Hits

While the freedom to choose your deliveries sounds ideal, it can take a toll on your DoorDash acceptance rate. For those aiming for the Top Dasher program, a low acceptance rate can be a stumbling block.

It's a trade-off: Do you aim for the perks of being a Top Dasher, or do you go for the immediate benefits of cherry-picking? Decisions, decisions in the world of gig economy work.

Potential for Fewer Dashes

If you're a dasher who prefers to decline more orders than you accept, beware. The DoorDash app's algorithm may prioritize drivers with higher acceptance rates, leaving you with fewer opportunities to dash.

This can lead to periods of low pay and just sitting around waiting for a good order to come in. So while cherry-picking might seem like a good strategy, it does come with the risk of fewer dashes.

Low Pay Despite Cherry-Picking

Cherry-picking doesn't always mean you'll strike gold. Low pay is still a reality many dashers face, even when being selective. Inconsistent tips and fluctuating base pay can sometimes leave you wondering if the cherry-picking strategy is really worth it.

One week you could be raking in the cash, and the next, you could be experiencing low acceptance rates and fewer dashes. The life of a DoorDash driver can vary from one week to another, making it a hustle that requires constant adaptation.

The Top Dasher Program: Is It Worth It?

Become a Top Dasher, and you're rewarded by DoorDash with more visibility and better orders. Sounds like a dream, right? But there's a catch—your acceptance rate has to stay above a certain threshold. Decline too many orders, and you're back to the dime-a-dozen pool of Dashers.

The Reality of DoorDash Driver Pay in 2023

In 2023, the pay landscape for DoorDash drivers is anything but stable. Given the varying factors like base pay, tips, and even bonuses from the Top Dasher program, calculating average hourly earnings can feel like chasing a moving target. While DoorDash promotes higher earning potentials, the reality for many is that low-paying orders, high gas prices, and long wait times at restaurants can seriously cut into earnings. The fluctuating nature of gig work means your income is hardly guaranteed, making the allure of cherry-picking more pronounced than ever.

Another layer to the financial uncertainty is the constant decline in acceptance rates when drivers choose to cherry-pick. With an emphasis on maintaining a specific acceptance rate to attain or keep Top Dasher status, drivers often find themselves at a crossroads. Do they prioritize their acceptance rates, or do they focus on the potential for better hourly pay through cherry-picking? It's a dilemma many face in the gig economy of 2023.

Last but not least, mileage can be a hidden drain on a DoorDash driver's pay. When you're dashing from one end of the town to the other for a meager payout, you're not just spending time but also money on fuel. With rising fuel costs, it becomes even more critical to be selective—another reason why many are drawn to cherry-picking as a strategy to maximize income while cutting down on unnecessary miles.

Some Additional Things to Consider

Your Financial Situation

If gig work like DoorDash is your bread and butter, cherry-picking might be a luxury you can't afford. Turning down too many orders could result in not making enough to cover your basic expenses, especially if DoorDash is your primary source of income. In such cases, accepting a majority of the orders that come your way could be essential for financial stability.

Your Career Goals

Are you using DoorDash as a stepping stone towards a bigger career goal? Maybe you're saving up for a course or trying to network within the restaurant industry. In that case, turning down gigs based solely on pay might not serve your long-term objectives. Accepting a wider range of orders can provide you with invaluable experience and contacts that could be beneficial down the line.

Your Personal Preferences

Ultimately, your personal preferences play a significant role in whether or not cherry-picking is right for you. If you value job security, benefits, and a steady income over the flexibility that comes with being an independent contractor, then cherry-picking might not align well with your career aspirations. It's crucial to balance the allure of higher-paying orders with what genuinely matters to you in your work-life scenario.

Your Choice, Your Livelihood

Ultimately, the decision to cherry-pick rests with you. But, make no mistake—this choice can affect your income, your ratings, and even your job security.

What About Other Services Like Uber Eats and Lyft?

Ever tried driving for Uber or Lyft? They've got their own pros and cons, but at least there’s some cash back on gas and other perks.

So, Should You Cherry-Pick Orders?

The conclusion is yours to make. As long as you're aware of the potential benefits and pitfalls, you can make an informed decision. And who knows, maybe DoorDash will take a cue from the drivers and make some changes.

In a world where being a DoorDash driver can be a financial rollercoaster, every tip helps—whether it's for your server or your DoorDash driver pay. Stay savvy out there, folks!

If you want to look at ways to maximize your gig economy income, join our free webinar to get everything you need to know about a unique and powerful option. No credit cards, no sales pitch—just pure, value-packed information. Trust us; you won’t want to miss this!